Officials can’t say they serve the people while taking shots at the public’s right to know
Arkansas Rep. David Ray, R-Maumelle, listens as Deputy Attorney General for Opinions Ryan Owsley discusses details of House Bill 1726 to a committee on March 29, 2023. The bill would have made major changes in Arkansas’ Freedom of Information law. Some of those changes are in a new bill for which Ray is lead sponsor in a special legislative session slated to begin Sept. 11, 2013. (Antoinette Grajeda/Arkansas Advocate)
Pardon me if you’ve heard this before: Arkansans’ right to know how their state and local governments operate is enshrined in a 56-year-old law called the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act.
During this year’s legislative session, some lawmakers attempted to punch gaping holes in the FOIA’s defense against government secrecy, large enough to make much of the law meaningless. Thankfully, they did not succeed.
But now Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders — apparently in a fit of pique with a local blogger, and with the support of key legislators — proposes to take a swing with a wrecking ball by hiding many state agency records from public view. Under the guise of protecting the safety and security of state officials, she also proposes to keep secret any details of trips she and others take at taxpayer expense using aircraft belonging to Arkansas State Police.
This bill is not government of the people, by the people, and for the people. This bill is government of the government, by the government and for the government. Legislators will have to decide if they represent the people or the government.
– Joey McCutchen, attorney and FOIA proponent
The details are in this piece of legislation that lawmakers will consider in a special session starting Monday and scheduled to end Wednesday.
With 40 House sponsors and 18 in the Senate, the bill aims to add to the state FOIA an exemption modeled on the “deliberative process exemption” contained in the federal version of the statute.
Attorney and FOIA warrior Joey McCutchen of Fort Smith noted in an email Friday that some have called this the “most abused exemption” in the federal government. “Others call the federal exemption the ‘withhold it because you want to exemption.’” That “just because I can” philosophy directly contravenes the stated intent of the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act:
McCutchen said Friday — and I agree — that “if this exemption becomes law, Arkansans will overnight go from [having] the strongest open records law in the country to the weakest. This bill is not government of the people, by the people, and for the people. This bill is government of the government, by the government and for the government. Legislators will have to decide if they represent the people or the government.”
The elements of the bill pertaining to security are nothing more than a smokescreen designed to keep a persistent user of the FOIA — attorney and blogger Matt Campbell — from obtaining information from Arkansas State Police about trips made by the governor and others in state aircraft. There’s even a clause that makes the secrecy retroactive to January of 2022. Campbell, who blogs under the Blue Hog Report name, in fact sued the ASP on Tuesday over its refusal to provide certain documents.
It’s unconscionable that the governor would suggest weakening a decades-old law that protects the right of all Arkansans, regardless of political affiliation, to keep an eye on their government to keep one persistent user of the FOIA. Sanders calls it “weaponization” and said the proposal isn’t aimed at any single FOIA requester.
McCutchen in his email called the bill’s security measure a Trojan Horse, and Campbell wrote in an email: “This is not about ‘security’ in any sense of the word.”
Indeed, the entire bill is basically a power grab and would be a stain on Arkansas’ historic role in making government accessible and transparent to its citizens.
I urge lawmakers to put the brakes on this runaway train.
SUPPORT NEWS YOU TRUST.
This commentary was first published by the Arkansas Advocate, part of the States Newsroom network of news bureaus with the Louisiana Illuminator. It’s supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Arkansas Advocate maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sonny Albarado for questions: [email protected]. Follow Arkansas Advocate on Facebook and Twitter.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.