Reform measure would dismantle ‘qualified immunity’ that shields bad police officers

House subcommittee to review police reform recommendation Tuesday

By: - February 22, 2021 6:14 pm
The utility belt of a police officer holds a handgun and a baton

The ACLU of Louisiana’s Justice Lab partners have filed 50 cases throughout Louisiana focusing on excessive police force, racial profiling, unreasonable searches, stops and seizures, and false arrests. (Photo by Juanmonino / iStock Getty Images)

A Louisiana House subcommittee will meet Tuesday to review a police reform recommendation that would dismantle the qualified immunity that blocks lawsuits against police officers who wrongfully kill or injure citizens. It is perhaps the most critical of the 18 recommendations being submitted by the legislature’s Police Training, Screening and De-escalation Task Force.

The House Qualified Immunity Subcommittee of House Civil Law and Procedure will meet at 10 a.m. to review, study and possibly amend the task force’s recommendation, which states in full: “No element of qualified immunity shall be available to law enforcement officers as a defense to liability for claims brought under state law for wrongful death, physical injury, or personal injury inflicted by law enforcement officers through any use of physical force in a manner determined by a finder of fact in a judicial proceeding to be unreasonable.” 

It is the only item of business on the subcommittee’s agenda, and it has the potential to bring significant reform to policing in Louisiana by allowing individual law enforcement officers to be held accountable for their misdeeds — at least under civil law. 

Qualified immunity is a legal doctrine that renders police officers and other public employees immune from lawsuits when they commit misconduct, violate someone’s rights or break the law. Though it can apply to many government employees, it is almost exclusively used by police officers.

“It has given some bad police officers some really strong protections,” said New Orleans civil rights attorney Bill Quigley.

Quigley said the recommendation, if adopted by legislators and signed into law, could be a game changer by ensuring that no one — not even police officers — are above the law, he said.

“This is a movement that is going on across the country,” Quigley said in a phone interview Monday. “The way it stands right now is police have ‘super protection’ under the law. They have more than any bus driver, airplane pilot, teacher, doctor, or anyone else. The result is there is very rarely any accountability for law enforcement in civil courts.”

Those who are opposed to such recommendations have often argued that a change in the law would open a floodgate of lawsuits against police and prevent officers from effective policing out of fear of being sued. However, judges and juries are often not sympathetic to people with frivolous claims, and the recommendation doesn’t seek to make police officers vulnerable, Quigley said.

“It’s not as if they’re stripped bare of protections,” he said. “They’re just afforded the same protections as everyone else.”

Civil Rights attorney William Most agreed with Quigley and pointed out that it would only apply to claims under state law in state courts — not federal courts, which is where a majority of civil rights lawsuits are handled. Nevertheless, he said, the recommendation is an essential starting point for real police reform.

“Qualified immunity shields officers who break the law from accountability for their actions,” Most said. “We need more accountability for these officers, not less — and so this change would be a victory for communities who have historically been harassed by police.” 

Louisiana lawmakers will consider and vote on any legislation that emerges from the task force’s recommendations during the upcoming session in April.



Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Wesley Muller
Wesley Muller

Wes Muller traces his journalism roots to 1997 when, at age 13, he built a hyper-local news website for his New Orleans neighborhood. Since then, he has freelanced for the Times-Picayune and worked on staff at WAFB/CBS, the Sun Herald and the Enterprise-Journal, winning awards from the SPJ, Associated Press, Mississippi Press Association and McClatchy. He also taught English as an adjunct instructor at Baton Rouge Community College. Muller is a New Orleans native, Jesuit High School alumnus, University of New Orleans alumnus and a U.S. Army veteran and former paratrooper. He lives in Southeast Louisiana with his two sons and wife.